Wednesday, July 18, 2012

On the cusp of the bubble

In my second year of college, I went to a sorority sister's home in suburban Columbus. I was shocked. The house looked like something out of a John Hughes movie, and I really, truly believed no one's house looked like that in real life. We were in the basement rec room when I asked to use a bathroom. 

"Oh, there's one down here," my friend said. "It's not completely finished, but you can use it." 

Finally, I thought to myself, something I understand: a crappy, unfinished basement bathroom. I was expecting a tiny toilet in a cramped corner closet, all hastily thrown together on a weekend. What I walked into was a nicely tiled, well-appointed room that was bigger than my childhood bedroom. I'm still not sure what was unfinished about it. Maybe some trim was missing? 

I went home that night and called my mom. 

"Why did you not tell me we were poor?!" 

"How did you not KNOW?" 


---


I started thinking about all of this because of this quiz about class in America and everyone's response to it. (I got a 50.) Where I'm from is not the same as where I'm at, and I'm simultaneously proud and frustrated by that. What I know for sure is the farther removed I am from my childhood, the more I appreciate it. 

---


I'm from a very small town in rural Ohio, a township actually, a crossroads with a church and a grange hall and a cemetery. I graduated with 87 kids, most of whom I had known since kindergarten. My parents, when they married, lived in rented houses in the county seat, which has a population of about 20,000. When I was 5, we moved to a trailer that they bought and put on my grandparents' property, about 12 miles north of town. My aunt and uncle also had a trailer on the property. My great grandma lived across the street and another uncle and aunt lived just a few miles away. 

My dad and grandpa were truck drivers and their big semis sat in the dust and gravel of the U-shaped driveway. The garage attached to my grandparents house was as big as a barn, bigger than the story-and-a-half house where Grandma and Grandpa had raised five kids. My mom worked at a factory, inspecting circuit boards, and that's where my parents met. My mom had been married before and had us girls, but Dad was Dad from the time I was 4 and my sister still was in diapers. (My biological father is something best left undiscussed.) My grandma worked at a factory sewing life vests. One of the first "jobs" I ever had was stamping the tags she had to sew into the things she made. She paid my sister and me a few pennies per slip. 


Our babysitter was a family friend. Her husband was a mechanic who owned his own garage. We used to play in the store room and to this day, between him and my truck-driving dad and grandpa, I find the smell of oil and gas oddly soothing. She raised show dogs. Another one of my early jobs was being a runner at dog shows. 

We didn't farm, but we always had big gardens and canned green beans and froze corn, which usually came from farming neighbors in exchange for the work my dad and grandpa did on their tractors. My great grandma, Little Grandma (she was under 5 feet tall), got government cheese and peanut butter and Grandma always said that stuff, the peanut butter that came in the big, white-labeled can, made the best peanut butter cookies and buckeyes at Christmas. 


For the most part, everyone I went to school with was the same. I remember being a little envious of kids whose families didn't live in trailers or kids whose moms came on every field trip. There were one or two kids whose families were noticeably better off -- they had Nikes or real Trapper Keepers, and their parents owned their own business or worked for one of the bigger factories in the region -- but most of us were the same. Our parents were mechanics, truck drivers, factory workers, teachers, farmers or secretaries. We were almost all white. One girl, a friend of mine, was Korean and adopted -- and was teased a lot about it. In my sister's grade, there was a black boy who went to a different school in the county and he was known as the Black Kid from X School District.


If anything, I figured my family was better off than others. Mom and Dad always had at least one new car. We didn't get presents randomly, but I don't ever remember being disappointed on Christmas morning. I always had clean clothes. We always had plenty to eat. My parents spoke disdainfully of people who went on welfare. We camped in the summer and rode four-wheelers. My grandpa O -- Mom's dad -- bought us new winter coats every year or two. My dad and uncles built a deck on the trailer, and Dad also built a special desk for me -- it was a little cupboard that a desk folded out of -- because I loved to write. I was in 4-H. When we got old enough to stay home alone, I spent the summer reading and doing laundry, hanging it out on the clothes line to dry, and eating tomato sandwiches. We didn't get allowances; the work we did was just part of being in the family.


My dad and uncle drank Bud Light and just about everyone smoked. Mom finally quit when I was in high school; Dad didn't give up his Camels until I was in college. We watched Roseanne and Cheers and, if Dad had the remote, Dukes of Hazzard and MASH reruns. 


When I was 14, my grandparents sold the house at the Copsey Compound to my parents and moved into our trailer. We basically swapped houses, and that's how things are still, though Grandma and Grandpa did get a new trailer a couple years ago. My sister and I shared the upstairs, which was two connected rooms. We turned one into a kind of sitting room for us and I had a real desk, a refinished vanity table from my mom's childhood bedroom set. She grew up in town -- definitely middle class, when you could do that with a father who worked at General Motors and a stay-at-home mom. That's how I defined class then: coming from in town or country. 


I got a job at a grocery store at 16, where I made friends with and started dating a boy from my class who I had ignored as being too country and not smart enough. To be fair, he had made fun of me for being a bookworm. He was exactly what I needed then. He left the store to work on a farm, milking cows and pulling dead chickens out of the "free range" barn. (Chickens will peck each other to death, fyi.) He was sweet and would pick me up for a date covered in cow shit (he'd shower before we'd go out for real) and kept me from being an even bigger twit than I was. I wanted to go to college. I had big plans about leaving my little hick town. 


I decided at 14 to become a journalist because I wanted to write and realized a novelist wasn't going to pay the bills. Also because I had a teacher who told me I could. My school district was small, but had many, many teachers who were willing to spend extra time on a kid who wanted the attention. I was very lucky. I went to Ohio University because it was in-state and I got a scholarship -- and luckily it had a good journalism program. For all my big talk, I begged my mom to let me come home after my first week I was so homesick. The best thing she ever did was refuse to let me. I stayed at OU and flourished -- and then graduated early because a) all my friends had graduated, b) I was sick of college, of being an adult, but not and c) I was running out of money. 


I got a job within a month of graduating, but oh my god. I've never been so full of self-loathing as that month at home without a job. 


A couple of my cousins had started college and my uncle had gone back to school to get his nursing degrees. Mom was working on an associate's degree when I went to school. But I think I was the first person in my family to earn a traditional four-year degree going to a college away from home. I'm still paying off student loans, as are my parents.


---


Sorry if your eyes are glazed over, but this -- all of this -- is why I once nearly threw a very good friend out of my house when she declared ignorant voters with high school educations were the problem with America. (To be fair to us both: Lots of alcohol was involved.) 


My dad works road construction now. Mom still works in a factory. My sister is a hair stylist and my brother-in-law owns his own construction business. Whenever I bitch about my job, I feel guilty thinking about my dad working 12+-hour days in 100-degree heat, grinding asphalt.


I worry about how to keep my boys from growing up in a privileged bubble. I want them to know where their food comes from and how to hammer in a nail properly, how to do laundry and cook their own meals. I want them to have jobs that make their muscles hurt as much as I want them to have jobs that stretch their brains. I worry I'm depriving them of a childhood around their cousins, exploring the back field and getting dirty, as much as I'm proud they have a broader view of the world now, in preschool, than I did in college.


Where are you from? Where are your kids going to be from?

10 comments:

Cupcake Mama said...

I took the quiz too and I have to tell you that where I am now is a LOT different than how I grew up and I am not sure that is a good thing. I want the more worldly views and access to a better life and not worrying about money if you have to go to the dentist or need a prescription but not all the other crap. I really have no right answer but I am continuing to search.

Erica said...

I am so glad you wrote about this! I was also intrigued by the bubble quiz although I ended up being on the complete opposite side of it. I guess no matter how you grow up, you think of that as "normal" and I guess for me that was a suburb.
My parents never did factory or farm jobs. My dad was always in managerial roles and my mom is a tech in the hospital. Although my mom puts in long days on her feet, it's indoors and in the medical field. But she's not college educated. We did have a new tract house, nice cars and real trapper keepers. So that was that.

Uri and I talk about Anna and how her life is so different from what ours was. Uri grew up with less, his parents were hippies and always kind of scraping by. We look at Anna and how she's already flown so many places and been to really fancy restaurants and hotels - it's just such a trip. I never thought of it as a bubble but I guess it kind of is.

When I think of what I want for her, I mainly just want her to enjoy life and get the most out of it that she can. To get an education but not be too stressed. To feel like she has options and feel free to be who she wants to be. I want her to be grateful for her opportunities and not squander them. We'll see how it goes.

Hermit said...

You did it again...I got all teary-eyed! I love when you write about childhood and home because you say what I want to say but don't know how. I guess I should take that quiz.

Erin said...

I scored a 39. I never thought of my childhood as part of the bubble. We lived in suburban Columbus (I went to high school with Michelle), my mom stayed home until I was in middle school and my dad sold insurance. Sometimes he was out of work, but we never went without. I remember one year when money was tight, I was afraid to ask for $10 to buy a yearbook. It think that summer I also got to go to horse camp. I never knew how they paid for it.

We didn't have fancy stuff in our house. My dad made a good portion of our furniture in our garage with tools he made himself. My mom gardened and sewed clothes and made most of our window coverings. Both of their childhoods were filled with financial struggles and I think they were barely getting by but refused to admit it, and I think they wanted something more for my sister and me.

I don't really think of myself as "upper middle class" even though that's what the quiz says I am.

My kids are from a much different city than I grew up in. It's about the size of Dayton, but more rural and smack in the middle of coal country/farmland near the Ohio River. Evansville, Ind., feels far more southern than Columbus, Ohio, ever did. I have said Evansville is the biggest small town I have ever seen.

However, we are not normal Evansville-ians. We are more educated than most of America (I think only 10 percent have MAs, which we both have, and something like 27 percent of the US have completed BAs). I work in a school where ALL the student body wants to go to college. I remind my students frequently that those ambitions are not America's norm. My husband works at a university, again with some of the town's most highly educated people. Most of my interactions are with Evansville's upper crust. DId I really just say that?

Still, there are cornfields and soybean all around my house, and I make sure my kids know what they are and what comes from them. I don't want them growing up entitled or spoiled. I say NO a lot. I am careful about what we buy and how many toys I let the kids have. I don't want them to know we've started college funds because I want them to WORK for their education. If I can swing it, the best gift I could ever give them is the one my in-laws gave to my husband: graduating college debt free. I didn't. I can't imagine paying loan debt while putting two kids in daycare.

Your childhood is not unlike that of people I knew in high school. I always compared myself to some of my wealthier friends, but I'm glad my parents said NO and made me save money for 'splurge' items like Guess jeans or a leather jacket.

Since leaving home, my father's career and income has changed DRASTICALLY to the point where he now lives in a house with an in-ground pool and has three BMWs. Go figure.

Stephanie M. said...

I also am in a very different place (geographically, financially, economically) from where I grew up.

My parents live outside of a small town of 200 in Ohio on a couple acres they've owned since the late '70s. My mom graduated college in 1975 with a teaching degree, but worked at a box store and then a factory before being a stay-at-home mom. My dad was a supervisor at a Phillips plant that made TVs before graduating college when I was 4. Then he was in management at auto factories, but wasn't always employed because it's not the most stable industry.

My home life was very, very, eerily similar to yours, Hillary.

Contrast that with my husband's family: His mom's an interior decorator who works when it suits her because she doesn't need the money. His dad's a partner at a big law firm in Columbus. Josh grew up in one of the most affluent school districts in Ohio. Josh hasn't taken the quiz, but I imagine he'd be much lower than the 47 I got. Josh's mother once made the comment that the "most despicable" thing she thinks parents can do is let their children have college loan debt. (I'm still paying for college.)

Now I live in the LA suburbs... far from fields and hick towns and hick mentalities. It's what I thought I wanted when I was growing up, but it's definitely a world I don't quite fit in. I can't understand wanting to spend $500 on a purse. I can't understand owning or wanting a luxury car. I don't know how to reconcile these very different worlds for my future child. I second grateful for the opportunities and not squandering them.

d e v a n said...

I took that quiz and got a 47. I'm in a much different place, and my kids will grow up very differently than I did.

I grew up in a double wide on 5 acres. We raised our own chickens for eggs and meat, rabbits, cows and pigs too. We were POOR and I didn't realize until we weren't anymore.
My dad was a mechanic. My mom stayed home with us, but she never even graduated high school (they had my sister at only 17). We didn't buy things that didn't come from garage sales or WalMart.
Every time I walk into a body shop, I'm a kid again. The smell is just like home.

My kids are growing up in a suburban neighborhood, and my husband makes in one year what my parents probably lived on for 3 or 4. (and we aren't rich)It's much different than what I remember from my childhood.

Sarah said...

Loved this post. I came from the country, TECHNICALLY, but my dad worked in a unionized factory and my mom stayed home and baked cookies until we were in high school... we were not well off, especially since my dad also paid child support for my half sister, but definitely middle class. My husband grew up in the countryside of MI, but it was a more genuine country upbringing. So I'd say our kids will have it about the same as I did, maybe a little better, and a lot better than Jim did. Better financially speaking, of course. The rest, who knows.

k said...

Hillary, I loved this post with all my heart. I loved reading about how you grew up and what you think and feel about it.

To be honest, my score on the quiz (20) kind of befuddles me as I don't consider myself having a sequestered child- or adulthood.

I consider myself--and T is even more so--a bit of a mish mash.

PrairieMom said...

Beautifully written. Thank you for sharing it, and for thinking (and causing me to think) about these things.

Erica said...

This is really interesting. I scored a 39, although I think my hometown was a lot more blue-collar/country than came across in the specific questions. I still get excited that I live in the BIG CITY now (even if I'm on the very edge of it).